Audition Songs for It Shoulda Been You – By Character

Do you have an upcoming audition for It Shoulda Been You? Well unless you have specifically been asked to sing a song from the show that you’re auditioning for, it’s generally best not to. That said, you should still show off similar vocals and personality. So here’s our list of audition songs for It Shoulda Been Youbroken down by character.

Since It Shoulda Been You is a contemporary musical, the following songs are from contemporary shows as well. In addition there are lots of romance and relationship vibes below in order to match the style of the show.

Please note: This post contains affiliate links. This means that if you choose to make a purchase through one of the following links, we may earn a small commission on the sale at no additional cost to you. Please read our disclosure for more info.

Step 1: Read your audition details

Please read your audition details carefully, as they sometimes specify the type of song they’d like to hear (a ballad, something uptempo, etc.). Make sure to select a song that’s appropriate for your specific casting call.

Step 2: Get to know the show

In casting calls, they often ask for you to be “familiar with the show”. And even if it’s not requested, it’s generally assumed. One way to do this is to read through the synopsis while listening to the It Shoulda Been You cast album.

Step 3: Pick an audition song

Next, based on your personality and vocal type, decide whether you’d like to audition for the ensemble or a specific character. Keep in mind that just because you audition for a specific character doesn’t mean you will necessarily be chosen for that role.

There’s usually a spot on the audition form where you will be asked if you are open to being in the ensemble or accepting a different role. I would suggest ticking that box and taking whatever you are offered. Every The role is important, and being in a show provides you with valuable experience.

And on that same note, even if you audition for the ensemble (and not a specific character), there’s always a chance you might get chosen for a leading/supporting role!

To summarize, keep an open mind and try not to take the process too seriously. And when you’re ready, decide which character you’d like to audition for. And finally, choose a suitable song from the list below!


“After All” – Ever After Music➝

“Another Winter in a Summer Town” – Gray Gardens Music➝

“Love and Love Alone” – The Visit Music➝

“The Revolutionary Costume for Today” – Gray Gardens Music➝


“Even Though” – I Love You Because Music➝

“Get Out and Stay Out” – 9 to 5 Music➝

“I Have Found” – The Royal Family of Broadway Music➝

“Perfect” – Edges Music➝


“It’s Not About Me” – The Prom Music➝

“Jeanette’s Showbiz Number” – The Full Monty Music➝

“Never Get Married” – Honeymoon in Vegas Music➝

“The Cake I Had” – Gray Gardens Music➝


“Isn’t that Enough?” – Honeymoon in Vegas Music➝

“When She Smiles” – Lysistrat Jones Music➝

“You Don’t Need to Love Me” – If/Then Music➝

“You Never Know” – If/Then Music➝


“Home Calls” – Next Thing You Know Music➝

“Manhattan Bridge” – Next Thing You Know Music➝

“There Was John” – Tootsie Music➝

“You Can’t Be Everything You Want” – Next Thing You Know Music➝

Ensemble (Altos)

“Always Starting Over” – If/Then Music➝

“Just Not Now” – I Love You Because Music➝

“Lying There” – Edges Music➝

Ensemble (Baritones)

“Do Something” – Honeymoon in Vegas Music➝

“Favorite Places” – Ordinary Days Music➝

“I Think I Like Her” – Summer of ’42 Music➝

Ensemble (Bases)

“Come to an Agreement” – Honeymoon in Vegas [first half] Music➝

“I Like It Here” – The Story of My Life Music➝

“What Would You Do?” – If/Then Music➝

Ensemble (Contras)

“Calm” – Ordinary Days Music➝

“No Turning Back Now” – Circles Music➝

“Playing Nancy” – Groundhog Day Music➝

Ensemble (Mezzos/Sopranos)

“Anytime I Am There” – Elegies: A Song Cycle Music➝

“Don’t Say Another Word” – Next Thing You Know Music➝

“Losing Track of Time” – Summer of ’42 Music➝

Ensemble (Tenors)

“A Jerk Like Me” – When Midnight Strikes Music➝

“And I Breathe” – Next Thing You Know Music➝

“As Good As I Get” – Next Thing You Know Music➝

Psst… Here’s where you can find out your voice type!

Step 4: Select a monologue

If requested, here are a few audition monologues for It Shoulda Been You:

• “A Girl’s Guide to Chaos” in Solo!: The Best Monologues of the 80s – Women

• “It’s Best” from Elsewhere

• “Personally speaking” in Audition Arsenal for Men in Their 20s

• “Right Place, Right Time #2” in The Best Men’s Monologues from New Plays, 2019

• “Speechless” in Audition Arsenal for Men in Their 20s

Final Step: Prepare for your audit

After collecting your materials and getting familiar with the show, it’s time to move forward with the actual preparation. If you’re in need of some guidance on this step, you can always go through this FREE audition prep checklist!

Want more songs? Check out our DIY Rep Books for EVERY vocal type!

It Shoulda Been You Song List

Here’s a list of the musical numbers in It Shoulda Been You, along with which characters sing in each of them. Unless you have been asked to, do not choose any of the below songs for your audition! The following is more intended to be used for character research purposes.

*That said, if you’ve specifically been asked to sing a song from the show, you can find the sheet music for the best possible audition songs below.*

“I Never Wanted This” – Jenny

“This Day (Opening)” – Company

“Perfect” – Jenny, Rebecca

“It Shoulda Been You” – Murray, Marty, Judy, Aunt Sheila, Uncle Morty

“Who” – Marty, Jenny

“Back in the Day” – George, Brian

“Nice” – Judy, Georgette

“Albert’s Turn” – Albert, Walt, Mimsy, Jenny

“Where Did I Go Wrong” – Georgette

“Beautiful” – Jenny

“A Perfect Ending” – Company

“Love You Till the Day” – Greg, Annie

“Jenny’s Blues” – Jenny

“Whatever” – Marty

“A Little Bit Less Than” – Rebecca

“What They Never Tell You” – Judy

“That’s Family” – Judy, Georgette, Murray, George

“Finale” – Company

Which of these audition songs for It Shoulda Been You did you choose?

And what role are you auditioning for? We would love to hear all about it in the comments! And in the meantime, you can check out our database of best audition songs for other musicals.

Need extra help? You can go through this free audition prep checklist!

Sign up for your free audition prep checklist.

Stacy Karyn, author of Audition Songs for It Shoulda Been You.
Author: Stacy Karyn

Stacy Karyn is the founder of Theater Trip, author of The Thespian’s Bucket List, and creator of The Cast Album List. She has a TESOL drama certificate, a BA in theater, and has worked and interned with Broadway and Off-Broadway theaters.

Leave a Comment